• Climate Strike

 

When Being Seen Is Not Enough


Nov 19, 2026 | Joanne Lebert

Some of the harms linked to artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM) attract attention quickly: sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV), child labour, and mercury contamination. These issues are taken up by advocates and other external actors. Some are international, such as campaigners, consumers and policy makers far from the mine sites. Others are closer to home, including urban elites, politicians and state actors. Cast as vulnerable and in need of protection, women, children, and the environment compel these actors to step in and use their power and privilege to protect them. Women in particular are portrayed as victims without agency, waiting to be rescued, rather than as miners, earners and decision-makers in their own right.

The harms are real, and protection matters. Yet people living and working in ASM communities lead lives that cannot be reduced to narratives of harm and victimhood. They often understand their own vulnerabilities, and act on them, in ways outsiders do not recognize. When a single issue defines the problem, the response tends to be designed far from the mine site, by people who do not live with its consequences. Researchers, engineers, practitioners and policy makers develop standards, policies, regulations and initiatives, while the people these measures target are rarely consulted or recognized as experts.

The result is often top-down, exclusive and ill-fitting. These responses can miss the conditions that cause harm, overlook the strategies people already use to manage risk, and push that risk elsewhere. Worse, they can undermine or replace the solutions people have already devised.

These solutions may not always be acceptable to outsiders. In conflict-affected and fragile contexts, people often rely on relationships with customary leaders, local authorities, traders and one another to protect themselves and sustain their livelihoods. Maintaining these relationships can involve obligations and payments that responsible sourcing standards may regard as unacceptable. Understanding these arrangements does not mean endorsing them but ignoring them means designing responses for a world that does not exist.

These standards can also place considerable demands on miners. They often expect miners to meet a growing list of requirements, complete surveys, provide data and evidence of compliance, often without the means to make the necessary improvements or any compensation for their time. Miners rarely have a say in how these standards are designed, yet the data they provide mainly helps buyers manage their own risk. As a result, some miners may choose to sell to informal buyers who do not ask for evidence. At the same time, groups working on child labour, SGBV or mercury often work in silos and rarely see how these issues connect in people’s lives.

For women and children, the effects of this disconnect can be particularly harmful. The three examples below show how responses built around a single harm, and designed without the people they aim to protect, have had adverse effects.

When one harm defines the problem

In the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), women’s bodies became one of the ways the consequences of conflict were made visible. Accounts of SGBV drew, and continue to draw, international attention to the link between minerals and armed groups. They gave a human face to a conflict that could otherwise seem distant from the consumers and policy makers being asked to respond.

But this framing came with a limitation. Women could become visible primarily through what had been done to their bodies. They were cast as passive victims in need of saving by outsiders. Their agency, including the ways they protected themselves and their families, earned livelihoods, supported households, and navigated the same mining economies that international efforts were seeking to reform, was largely ignored.

In 2010, the United States adopted Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act, requiring publicly listed companies to disclose whether tin, tantalum, tungsten or gold (3TG) in their supply chains originated in DRC or adjoining countries. The provision emerged partly from advocacy campaigns about armed conflict and SGBV in and around mining communities. The U.S. Government Accountability Office was required to report annually on the rule’s effectiveness in promoting peace and security in Africa’s Great Lakes Region, including on rates of sexual violence. This proved difficult as there was no adequate baseline, reliable data were limited, and the causes of SGBV could not readily be linked to a Washington-based disclosure requirement. Women’s experiences had helped make the case for action, but the resulting system could not show whether they were any safer.

The problem ran deeper than measurement. Because women were seen as victims rather than actors, they were not treated as people with knowledge to contribute. They were not involved in designing the response, and the response did not address the underlying cause of their vulnerability: gender inequality and women’s lack of power. A framing that denies women’s agency is unlikely to produce solutions that strengthen it. In-country responses to Dodd-Frank, including certification, audits, mine-site inspections and new export procedures, were largely introduced from the top down with little attention to gender. Women were mostly absent from their design, partly because they were not seen as significant actors in the sector.

Ironically, many of these responses reinforced women’s exclusion, harmful stereotypes and marginalization. On the ground, a common reaction is to bar women from activities they had traditionally carried out, such as processing, because no mine site operator wants to risk being seen as non-compliant. Men were often well placed to take over these roles, and the income that came with them.

This exclusion has a cost. Research conducted in mining communities across DRC, Rwanda and Uganda found that ASM offers women significant earning opportunities. Women surveyed in DRC earned six times more from mining than from other income-generating activities, while those in Uganda earned approximately three times more. For women with few comparable economic opportunities, losing access to mining can have significant consequences.

When removing a child does not remove the problem

Efforts to address child labour in ASM show a similar pattern. The presence of a child at a mine site becomes not only evidence of a problem, but the focus of the response. A child at a mine site is a highly visible sign that something is wrong, but removing the child does not necessarily change the circumstances that brought them there.

Research with women artisanal cobalt miners in Kolwezi, DRC, through the first phase of IMPACT’s Her Security project found that children’s earnings were helping households cover basic needs. Women understood that children should not be working at mine sites, but some relied on their children’s income when their own earnings were not enough. The cost of schooling placed further pressure on household incomes. For younger children, a lack of safe childcare could also mean accompanying their mothers to the mine site.

Keeping children out of a particular mine site did not necessarily end the work. The research found that children could move between mine sites, change their hours, or go to sites where checks were less rigorous. Removing mining as an option could also push children towards other forms of work, including domestic work, which carries its own risks.  The child may no longer be visible at the mine site, but the reason they were there may not have disappeared.

Removing children from hazardous work remains essential. But if the conditions driving that work remain unchanged, the risk simply moves elsewhere. Looking beyond the mine site means understanding why a family may depend on a child’s earnings, and how women’s economic security and access to childcare shape those decisions. Addressing child labour therefore requires not only keeping children from hazardous work but also addressing the conditions they return to.

When protection pushes women out

Mercury use in artisanal and small-scale gold mining (ASGM) is a serious environmental and health concern, and it has become another single issue around which responses are built. Efforts to reduce or eliminate mercury often focus on introducing new processing technologies and equipment. These are usually designed and promoted by external actors, with the environment and human health as the main concern.

Yet these technologies do not arrive in a neutral setting. Women are often concentrated in less secure and lower-status roles, such as carrying and washing ore, processing and providing services, and they have less influence over decisions at the mine site. When new equipment changes how ore is processed, who owns and operates that equipment matters. Where men control it, women can be displaced from processing roles and lose income, autonomy and power.

Research carried out over the span of 10 years at gold mining sites in Kenya, Mozambique and Sierra Leone highlights this pattern. In Migori, Kenya, ball mills introduced in the 2000s expanded women’s access to processing work.[1] The later spread of cyanide leaching, however, allowed shaft owners, mostly men, to take control of processing and tailings, excluding many women.[2] In Sierra Leone and Mozambique, mechanised excavation ended women’s work carrying ore or pushed men into reprocessing work previously done mainly by women.[2][3] This pattern resonates with IMPACT’s own experience.

Concerns about mercury exposure and reproductive health have also shaped how women’s presence at mine sites is regulated. Article 5 of DRC’s Mining Code excludes pregnant women from ASM. Women miners have challenged this restriction, arguing that it prevents them from earning an income during pregnancy even when their work does not involve mercury or other dangerous chemicals. The measure treats pregnant women as bodies to be protected rather than as workers able to judge and manage their own risks. Framed as protection, it restricts a woman’s livelihood and removes her say in decisions about her own work.

Reducing exposure to mercury is essential. But a response that recognizes the danger and not the livelihood sees only part of the person it is trying to protect.

Beyond harm and victimhood

Seen from a distance, a woman at a mine site can easily become a category. Her exposure to mercury makes her vulnerable. Pregnancy can become grounds for restricting her presence, and an experience of violence becomes evidence for understanding conflict.

Seen as a person, the picture is larger.

The mine may be where she earns an income that is hard to earn elsewhere. Working there may also give her knowledge that no inspection can gain, and no reporting requirement can capture. The risks she faces are part of her reality, but not the whole of it.

Yet women in mining areas are still often described mainly as victims. This framing denies their agency. It overlooks the influence they use, the decisions they make, and the knowledge they hold, and it reinforces the stereotypes that keep them out of decision making. Over several years, collaboration between researchers and practitioners working on gender and ASM moved beyond a narrow focus on women as survivors of SGBV. It examined women’s livelihoods and how they navigate, and sometimes use, existing structures of power. As the evidence grew, women could no longer be understood only through vulnerability, because their economic roles and knowledge had become harder to ignore.

This is where visibility and power come apart. Systems have become increasingly capable of seeing people affected by mining. They identify vulnerable groups, document risks, collect data from mine sites, and follow minerals through supply chains. Artisanal miners have become highly visible as sources of data — which itself is converted into value for company derisking — yet remain far less visible as people whose knowledge should shape how these systems work. Being visible to a system does not mean influencing it.

Meaningful participation begins when the knowledge people bring can affect the decisions being made. Their experience should be able to change how a problem is understood and how a response is designed. It should also help institutions recognize when an intervention is creating consequences that were not anticipated.

For environmental peacebuilding, the challenge is therefore larger than ensuring that women are present. Networks can help by connecting community knowledge with institutions able to change policy and practice, and by bringing together groups that have worked on child labour, SGBV and mercury separately. People whose lives make environmental and social problems visible need meaningful influence over the responses built around them.

A single harm may have helped make many of these problems visible in the first place. But a person is never only evidence of harm or a site of risk, and never only a victim. They have a livelihood, knowledge, agency, and a stake in the decisions being made.

True recognition must go beyond acknowledging vulnerability. It means communities having the power to influence decisions, shape solutions and determine their own futures.  

About the Author

Joanne Lebert serves as IMPACT’s Executive Director, leading the organization’s efforts to improve how natural resources are managed in contexts where security and human rights are at risk. She has worked extensively to advance responsible mineral sourcing and address conflict minerals, including supporting Central African governments in developing and implementing a regional strategy. Joanne is a policy advisor, frequent guest speaker, and trainer for policymakers, private sector representatives, and civil society organizations.


[1] Buss, D. and Kinyanjui, S. (2026). Flowing Here and There: Border Making and Artisanal and Small-Scale Gold Mining in Western Kenya. Draft paper presented at the ABORNE Conference, Lagos, July 2026.

[2] Rutherford, B. (2026). Assessing “Foreigners” in the Mozambican-Zimbabwean Border Zone: Connected Borderlands, Moral Politics, and Gendered Livelihoods in Artisanal Gold Mining Sites in Manica, Mozambique. Draft paper presented at the ABORNE Conference, Lagos, 2026.

[3] Rutherford, B. and Buss, D. (2026). Gendering Gold ASM in Kenya, Mozambique, and Sierra Leone. Presentation, Carleton University.